Discussion:What are "Reasonable Fees"?
From TaxAlmanac
Discussion Forum Index --> Tax Questions --> What are "Reasonable Fees"?
| 15 August 2007 | |
| I need some guidance regarding reasonable fees. I am expanding my business (tax prep & bookkeeping). I will be adding quarterly payroll filing for several new clients who are looking for monthly bookkeeping services. I already prepare individual & small business returns. I'm in the Atlanta area. Not sure if this makes a difference.
I'd really like some suggestions on monthly bookkeeping, quarterly payroll filing and tax prep fees. Also, is there normally a "set-up fee" charged for new clients. Thanks. | |
| August 15, 2007 | |
| For quarterly filings, I charge 100 for single employee, and 150 for 2 or more. Attend a seminar where you can get some comparative info from pros in your area...or get out on the street and sell a bit so that you can see what others are charging, and how. | |
| 15 August 2007 | |
| What about monthly bookkeeping? Is $125 per month reasonable? I'm just not sure what the going rate is. I have a client who I have provided bookkeeping services for about 5 years. I started out charging him $75 per month and still charge $75 per month. He provides me with a bank statement and check register. I provide him with a bank reconciliation, balance sheet, P&L, and a detailed list of income & expenditures.
I'll be doing the same for a new client, but will also provide federal & state withholding figures per month (so client can hold back funds) and also quarterly tax filing. Would you increase the monthly rate if calculating withholdings? | |
| August 15, 2007 | |
| Can't answer that here, like that. Depends on the time and work involved. What do you feel is fair per hour? And how does that fee meet that? $75 would be lite, even for the tiniest clients, in my opinion...these days, the range is probably between twice that and up...way up if the company's big enough. Check with some orgs that you may belong to to see if they've got some data you can compare to. | |
| 15 August 2007 | |
| CPI 1st half 2007 205.709 http://www.bls.gov/cpi/cpid07fv.pdf
CPI 1st half 2002 178.9 http://www.bls.gov/cpi/cpid02sv.pdf $75 X 205.7/178.9 = $86 Assuming you have gotten no smarter and/or have added not technological improvements in the intervening years for which you might be able to grant yourself an increase, just based on the CPI you should be bumping it to at least $86. But what are you doing for $75/mo? Not much, I hope. | |
| 16 August 2007 | |
| I use industry averages that are fairly easy to obtain. And I adjust for the local economy (my area is about average I think). Inuit did a survey recently, they probably have it on their website. | |
| 16 August 2007 | |
| Capmark- My firms provides bookkeeping & payroll to many clients (well over 400 combined)
My advice which has been very successful for me is to not charge by the hour. Look at the clients work how organized are they , how complicated it is and then set a price fixed per month, once per year you review the account and make any adjustments needed up or down.. This will make the client happy because they now know what to expect and it also helps you with your own budgeting because you know how much is coming in. Any example would be - A client who has a bar has 10 employees, writes approximately 45 checks a month, appears to be well organized. I will prepare the paychecks, all quarterlies and deposits, w-2s & w-3, monthly P&L, and WA state monthly sales tax return. And for this I will charge about $300 per month. Then once a year around the anniversary date I review the account if payroll increased or he is not as organized as he once was, I increase the fee. Likewise if payroll decreases I would lower the fee. I hope this helps, it is how I do it , and that is not to say it is the only way it is just the way that works for me. Good Luck | |
| 16 August 2007 | |
| Easy....Call local bookkeping outfits and ask them what they charge. | |
Vermontcpa (talk|edits) said: | 17 August 2007 |
| Consider how much time each deliverable will take and try to price it at an hourly rate that you think is fair. I am with sea tax though if you can work out a monthly or quarterly rate then that works best but call out exactly what services that number will include and exclude. Then you can charge an hourly for anything that comes up thats out of the ordinary.
Also do not be afraid to charge more. Early on, CPAs almost always make this mistake and then the client faxes them a W-2 with $1m in wages and you feel silly that you were pondering charging $150 or $250 for the return.. its your time.. charge accordingly.. if they say no thats ok too......good luck also I would avoid direct mailing advertising as that did nothing for me. Blew thousands the first year with very little return. | |
| 17 August 2007 | |
| I agree with Sea-Tax (although I'm a Yankee Fan) re charging a flat fee. I agree that the client knows how much to pay each month and the amount of work probably doesn't vary that much each month. Figure how much time you probably will spend on the client on the average and multiply that by your hourly fee. that becomes your flat fee and you adjust if after a couple of years experience. | |
| 17 August 2007 | |
| Just be a bit careful with flat fees...if you need to increase due to fluctuations, clients can get quirky about that. Sure, it may only be an additional 20 checks written out of a bank account, but what kind of checks were they? If payroll, then you have additional work, if F/A, then you have additional work, etc. etc.
At a large firm I worked for, we had a flat fee for bkkping clients....but charged per transaction, and other hard and soft costs. The PIC then calculated write up/write down for reasonableness. Bottom line, first couple of months was based on a set up fee and the other months then were average of a few months transactions. Worked for him!!! | |
| 17 August 2007 | |
| Sandy what do you think a reasonble per transaction fee would be?
$3.00 ? | |
| 18 August 2007 | |
| Can you do my books for $75 a month? Sweet merciful crap that's cheap. I hope it takes you an hour to do the work or you live in South America and $75/month makes you the wealthest person in the pueblo.
My rule of thumb is recovery. Generally, I expect 90%+ recovery of my bill rate. For write up work I am willing to reduce that recovery rate to about 70%. If my typical rate is $100/hr and I spend 10 hours a month doing write up work then I expect to bill my client $700.00 a month. If the recovery rate is 50% or less than there is a problem. I need to drop the client because of opportunity costs or increase my fee structure with them. On the bill, I separately delineate out of pocket expenses for postage, software charges, etc. | |
Bottom Line (talk|edits) said: | 19 August 2007 |
| I too am wondering what the recovery rate is.
Capmark - figure out how much you want/need to make per hour. (Remember, you won't make any money charging $20/hour because you have expenses.) Then estimate how long it will take you to do the work. When giving a quote, I give a range instead of an exact amount. Be sure to take variables into account: Will the work be done at your office or the client's? Is this a rush project? What kind of conditions are the records in? How many questions do you have to ask the client? How much "help" do you get from the client? (I charge extra for "help" because it slows me down and annoys me.) | |
| 19 August 2007 | |
| hehehe; Tex for per transaction, it is much cheaper...only about .25 not 3.00. Some software packages can print out a list of the number of trx. The way I determine is what I was taught:
Flat fee plus per trx, plus payroll tax calcs, plus sales tax returns, plus plus plus The fee is only for inputting...the setup fee includes some things such as a binder for them to keep, printed g/l, b/s, p&l, bank rec, etc. I can then write up/write down based on # of trx....to go up on a monthly client, they don't understand they used their debit card 200 x in a month so it has to increase by the number of trx.... | |
| 19 August 2007 | |
| Also...sorry....my mind is racing a mile a minute:
DON'T FORGET THE B**CH TAX!!!! hehe | |
Bottom Line (talk|edits) said: | 19 August 2007 |
| And the whine and "I hate the government" fees! And the not following your advice and then blaming you for the bad outcome fee. | |
| 19 August 2007 | |
| HEHEHEHE; and did I fail to mention the B**CH tax? Sorry; have a crazy lady on my hands recently...hehehehehehe
Dont you love the ones that HATE the government? What am I paying for? GO BACK TO YOUR COUNTRY THEN !!! | |
Bottom Line (talk|edits) said: | 19 August 2007 |
| Then they proceed to tell you what specifically the government spends tax money on that they don't like. I don't care what your political beliefs are. I have no control over it. Call your Congressman and complain! I don't have time to listen to it. | |
| 19 August 2007 | |
| How bout the "I HATE BUSH TAX"...they are not going to pay until he is out of office!!
Reminds me of a client who HATED the FL unemployment rate...he REFUSED to pay it, even though he had the revolving door....no employee reached over 7K per year in wages.... Notices, intents to levy, etc. he then would pay...it was his stance again "BIG GOVERNMENT"...not that it did not cost him hundreds in penalties...hehe | |


